BCG Rise and Fall
It has been a year since I published the series of reviews dedicated to big consulting companies’, so-called, ‘blockchain competencies’. In those reviews Boston Consulting Group (BCG) stands relatively high in the informal ranking of global consulting houses’ familiarity with DLT, right after PWC and ahead of McKinsey.
However, in their latest ‘Rise Of DeFi’ Report (sponsored by crypto.com and dated September 2020) the group of BCG Amsterdam employees managed to surprise me by lowering their analytics’ standards to the level, which makes this piece almost useless even for the undereducated corporate management types, which are the usual target auditory of such works.
Despite 2019–2020 signaling a start of the whole new epoch in the life of our industry, it looks like not much have changed in ‘corporate consultants’ approach to crypto. It still remains superficially transactional and reveals a lack of fundamental understanding and practical involvement with DLT projects.
Do not take me wrong, I highly appreciate this paper’s positive tone in which it speaks about DeFi. After all it serves our cause :)
However, even if this report is ‘sponsored’, wouldn’t be expected from BCG to deliver the objective, professional, based on practical examples review instead of just producing a plain-vanilla version of ‘DLT propaganda’?
Quote: ‘Despite the value SMEs add through innovation and entrepreneurship, their banking needs have not been met, because for centuries, financial services have been delivered through centralized parties who act as trusted intermediaries between economic agents.’
Moreover, BCG consultants go as far as to downplay the most serious threat to DeFi existence — that of govs crack-down on its major development teams, most of which are sited around us, here, in SF and area.
Quote: ‘The FATF recommendation as of today is that if the DeFi protocol is sufficiently decentralised and the entity behind it is not involved in day-to-day operations, it may not be classified as Virtual Asset Service Providers (VASPs) and hence is immune from the Travel Rule.’
As if SEC has ever restricted itself in its actions because of some kind of ‘recommendations’ coming from EU bureaucrats :)
[Please, do not forget that I am not your financial advisor and all above was not intended to be a financial advise, of course. You’ve got to use your own gray matter enclosed between both of your ears to take all important as well as unimportant financial decisions.]
For the original version of this article, please, refer to: http://svetrating.com/texts/85/
Image: View of Boston, 18th century
What Is SVET Rating?
Hidden Fundamentals' Leading Indicator
- Security (safety): for defenders (ISFJ- The Protector: Warm-hearted and dedicated, they are always ready to protect the people they care about.);
- Velocity (scalability): for megalomaniacs (ENTJ- The Commander: Outspoken and confident, they are great at making plans and organizing projects.);
- Engineering (design): for geeks (INTJ- The Architect: High logical, they are both very creative and analytical.);
- Transparency (decentralization): for crypto punks (ISTP- The Crafter: Highly independent, they enjoy new experiences that provide first-hand learning.);
- Singularity (uniqueness): for individualists (ISFP- The Artist: Easy-going and flexible, they tend to be reserved and artistic.);
- Volume (market): for globalists (ESFP- The Performer: Outgoing and spontaneous, they enjoy taking center stage.);
- Empathy (enthusiasm): for tribes (ESTP- The Persuader: Out-going and dramatic, they enjoy spending time with others and focusing on the here-and-now.);
- TimeLine (road-map): for visionaries (INFP- The Mediator: Idealistic with high values, they strive to make the world a better place.);
- Solution (business): for dealmakers (ESTJ- The Director: Assertive and rule-oriented, they have high principles and a tendency to take charge.);
- Validity (legality): for lawyers (ISTJ- The Inspector: Reserved and practical, they tend to be loyal, orderly, and traditional.);
- Equity (finance): For venture capitalists (INFJ- The Advocate: Creative and analytical, they are considered one of the rarest types.);
- Team: for friends (ESFJ- The Caregiver: Soft-hearted and outgoing, they tend to believe the best about other people.);
- Sustainability (stability): for sages (INTP- The Thinker: Quiet and introverted, they are known for having a rich inner world.);
- Value (venture): for adventurers (ENTP- The Debater: Highly inventive, they love being surrounded by ideas and tend to start many projects (but may struggle to finish them).);
- Engagement (usability): for pragmatics (ENFJ- The Giver: Loyal and sensitive, they are known for being understanding and generous.);
- Transactions (speed): for travelers (ENFP- The Champion: Charismatic and energetic, they enjoy situations where they can put their creativity to work.).
Here might be your Review.
Why Shall You Use SvetRating?
To make our Industry better by sharing your honest opinion and applying your professional expertise.
To objectively weigh up the pros and cons of your project.
To compare opinions of the enthusiasts and experts.